SC Administrative Law Court Decisions

Department of Insurance

Insurance Rate Cases

• 2008
• 2006
• 2005
• 2003
• 2002
• 2001
• 2000
• 1999
• 1998
• 1997
• 1996
• 1995
• 1994

2008

07-ALJ-09-0456-CC - - National Council on Compensation Insurance, Inc. vs. SCDOI - 5/22/2008

2006

05-ALJ-09-0277-CC - - National Council on Compensation Insurance, Inc. vs. SCDOI, et al - 10/2/2006
05-ALJ-09-0355-CC - - National Council on Compensation Insurance, Inc. vs. SCDOI, et al - 10/2/2006
05-ALJ-09-0364-CC - - Companion Property and Casualty Insurance Company vs. SCDOI - 10/2/2006
05-ALJ-09-0406-CC - - Consumer Advocate for the State of South Carolina vs. SCDOI - 10/2/2006

2005

05-ALJ-09-0159-CC - - Allstate Indemnity Company vs. SCDOI - 7/22/2005
05-ALJ-09-0227-CC - - Allstate Insurance Company vs. SCDOI - 7/22/2005
05-ALJ-09-0277-CC - - National Council on Compensation Insurance, Inc. vs. SCDOI - 8/30/2005
05-ALJ-09-0294-CC - - National Council on Compensation Insurance, Inc. vs. SCDOI - 8/30/2005

2003

02-ALJ-09-0537-CC - - National Council on Compensation Insurance, Inc. vs. DOI and Elliott F. Elam, Jr., Acting Consumer Advocate for the State of South Carolina - 2/26/2003
03-ALJ-09-0002-CC - - South Carolina Wind & Hail Underwriting Association vs. DOI - 3/18/2003
03-ALJ-09-0109-CC - - Allstate Indemnity Company vs. DOI - 4/14/2003
03-ALJ-09-0110-CC - - Allstate Indemnity Company vs. DOI - 4/14/2003
03-ALJ-09-0210-CC - - State Farm Fire and Casualty Company vs. DOI - 11/17/2003
03-ALJ-09-0324-CC - - Nationwide Mutual Fire Insurance Company vs. DOI - 11/26/2003

2002

02-ALJ-09-0018-CC - - American Family Home Insurance vs. SCDOI - 5/21/2002
02-ALJ-09-0019-CC - - Nationwide Mutual Fire Insurance vs. SCDOI - 5/31/2002
02-ALJ-09-0020-CC - - Selective Insurance Company of South Carolina vs. SCDOI - 1/29/2002
02-ALJ-09-0021-CC - - State Auto Property and Casualty Insurance Company vs. SCDOI - 3/6/2002
02-ALJ-09-0065-CC - - Fairmont Insurance Company vs. SCDOI, et al - 5/20/2002
02-ALJ-09-0066-CC - - Employers Insurance of Wausau vs. SCDOI - 4/18/2002
02-ALJ-09-0067-CC - - TIG Premier Insurance Company vs. SCDOI - 5/20/2002
02-ALJ-09-0079-CC - - American Modern Home Insurance Company vs. SCDOI - 5/21/2002
02-ALJ-09-0117-CC - - Insurance Services Office, Inc. vs. SCDOI - 7/30/2002
02-ALJ-09-0118-CC - - State Farm Fire and Casualty Company vs. SCDOI - 7/16/2002

2001

00-ALJ-09-0602-CC - - Companion Property & Casualty Insurance Company vs. SCDOI, et al - 1/31/2001
00-ALJ-09-0687-CC - - National Council on Compensation Insurance Inc. vs. SCDOI - 10/23/2001
01-ALJ-09-0182-CC - - CGU Insurance Company vs. SCDOI - 5/29/2001
01-ALJ-09-0183-CC - - General Accident Insurance Company vs. SCDOI - 5/29/2001
01-ALJ-09-0184-CC - - National Grange Insurance Company vs. SCDOI - 5/29/2001
01-ALJ-09-0314-CC - - Horace Mann Insurance Company vs. SCDOI, et al - 10/2/2001
01-ALJ-09-0336-CC - - American Reliable Insurance Company vs. SCDOI, et al - 9/28/2001
01-ALJ-09-0395 - - Allstate Insurance Company vs. SCDOI, et al - 10/1/2001
01-ALJ-09-0396 - - Allstate Insurance Company vs. SCDOI, et al - 10/1/2001

2000

00-ALJ-09-0055-CC - - National Casualty Company vs. SCDOI, et al - 5/4/2000
00-ALJ-09-0056-CC - - Standard Fire Insurance Company vs. SCDOI - 4/10/2000
00-ALJ-09-0086-CC - - State Auto Property and Casualty Insurance Company vs. SCDOI, et al - 4/19/2000
00-ALJ-09-0087-CC - - Harleysville Mutual Insurance Company vs. SCDOI - 4/4/2000
00-ALJ-09-0088-CC - - Northland Insurance Company vs. SCDOI, et al - 5/3/2000
00-ALJ-09-0321-CC - - American Modern Home Insurance Company vs. SCDOI, et al - 8/1/2000
00-ALJ-09-0488-CC - - South Carolina Reinsurance Facility vs. SCDOI, et al - 10/18/2000
00-ALJ-09-0573-CC - - Nationwide Mutual Fire Insurance Company vs. SCDOI - 11/9/2000
00-ALJ-09-603-CC - - Auto-Owners Insurance Company vs. SCDOI, et al - 12/5/2000
99-ALJ-09-0544-CC - - Horace Mann Insurance Company vs. SCDOI, et al - 2/15/2000
99-ALJ-09-0599-CC - - South Carolina Reinsurance Facility vs. SCDOI - 1/7/2000

1999

98-ALJ-09-0575-CC - - South Carolina Reinsurance Facility vs. SCDOI - 1/4/1999
98-ALJ-09-0631-CC - - Insurance Services Office, Inc. vs. SCDOI - 3/10/1999
98-ALJ-09-0645-CC - - Insurance Services Office, Inc. vs. SCDOI, et al - 2/22/1999
98-ALJ-09-0682-CC - - National Council on Compensation Insurance, Inc. vs. SCDOI - 3/30/1999
98-ALJ-09-0705-CC - - South Carolina Department of Consumer Affairs vs. SCDOI - 1/20/1999
98-ALJ-09-0709-CC - - South Carolina Department of Consumer Affairs vs. SCDOI, et al - 2/24/1999
99-ALJ-09-0010-CC - - National Council on Compensation Insurance, Inc. vs. SCDOI - 3/30/1999
99-ALJ-09-0011-CC - - South Carolina Department of Consumer Affairs vs. SCDOI, et al - 2/25/1999
99-ALJ-09-0080-CC - - Insurance Services Office, Inc. vs. SCDOI - 4/9/1999
99-ALJ-09-0092-CC - - State Capital Insurance Company vs. SCDOI - 3/16/1999
99-ALJ-09-0093-CC - - American Professional Insurance Company vs. SCDOI - 3/16/1999
99-ALJ-09-0316-CC - - Nationwide Mutual Fire Insurance Co. vs. SCDOI - 10/8/1999
99-ALJ-09-0317-CC - - Auto-Owners Insurance Company vs. SCDOI - 9/8/1999
99-ALJ-09-0448-CC - - Allstate Insurance Company vs. SCDOI - 9/9/1999

1998

98-ALJ-09-0423-CC - - State Farm Fire and Casualty Insurance Company vs. SCDOI - 11/30/1998
97-ALJ-09-0702-CC - - South Carolina Reinsurance Facility vs. SCDOI, et al - 1/23/1998
97-ALJ-09-0709-CC - - Continental Insurance Company vs. SCDOI, et al - 1/20/1998
97-ALJ-09-0723-CC - - South Carolina Wind and Hail Underwriting Association vs. SCDOI, et al - 1/10/1998
97-ALJ-09-0727-CC - - Insurance Services Offices, Inc. vs. SCDOI - 2/9/1998
98-ALJ-09-0067-CC - - Betty S. Buskey vs. SCDOI - 6/15/1998
98-ALJ-09-0148-CC - - Nobel Insurance Company vs. SCDOI - 3/27/1998
98-ALJ-09-0176-CC - - State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company vs. SCDOI - 5/4/1998
98-ALJ-09-0256-CC - - American Modern Home Insurance Company vs. SCDOI - 6/26/1998
98-ALJ-09-0257-CC - - American Family Home Insurance Company vs. SCDOI, et al - 6/26/1998
98-ALJ-09-0420-CC - - American Bankers Insurance Company of Florida vs. SCDOI - 11/16/1998
98-ALJ-09-0424-CC - - State Farm General Insurance Company vs. SCDOI - 11/30/1998

1997

96-ALJ-09-0518-CC - - INSURANCE SERVICES OFFICE, INC. vs. SCDOI - 1/1/1997
97-ALJ-09-0006-CC - - South Carolina Reinsurance Facility vs. SCDOI - 3/19/1997
97-ALJ-09-0152-CC - - South Carolina Farm Bureau Mutual Insurance Company vs. SCDOI - 7/2/1997
97-ALJ-09-0219-CC - - Insurance Services Offices, Inc. vs. SCDOI - 8/19/1997
97-ALJ-09-0222-AP - - Doris Gardner vs. SCDOI - 8/1/1997
97-ALJ-09-0496-CC - - South Carolina Reinsurance Facility vs. SCDOI - 11/3/1997

1996

95-ALJ-09-0150-CC - - The Cincinnati Insurance Company, et al vs. SCDOI - 7/12/1996
95-ALJ-09-0665-CC - - Allstate Insurance Company vs. SCDOI - 1/8/1996
95-ALJ-09-0733-CC - - South Carolina Reinsurance Facility vs. SCDOI - 1/15/1996
95-ALJ-09-0765-CC - - INSURANCE SERVICES OFFICE, INC vs. SCDOI - 3/4/1996
95-ALJ-09-0787-CC - - American Economy Insurance Company vs. SCDOI - 2/21/1996
96-ALJ-09-0016-CC - - South Carolina Reinsurance Facility vs. SCDOI, et al - 4/11/1996
96-ALJ-09-0017-CC - - INSURANCE SERVICES OFFICE, INC. vs. SCDOI - 4/16/1996
96-ALJ-09-0033-CC - - ALLSTATE INSURANCE COMPANY vs. SCDOI - 4/11/1996
96-ALJ-09-0041-CC - - Federated Rural Electric Insurance Corporation vs. SCDOI - 4/10/1996
96-ALJ-09-0041-CC - - Federated Rural Electric Insurance Corporation vs. SCDOI - 4/24/1996
96-ALJ-09-0042-CC - - State Farm Fire and Casualty Insurance Company vs. SCDOI - 3/29/1996
96-ALJ-09-0043-CC - - State Farm Fire and Casualty vs. SCDOI - 5/1/1996
96-ALJ-09-0052-CC - - South Carolina Wind and Hail Underwriting Association vs. SCDOI - 5/6/1996
96-ALJ-09-0053-CC - - Automobile Insurance Co. of Hartford, Conn., et al vs. SCDOI - 4/11/1996
96-ALJ-09-0055-CC - - Pennsylvania National Mutual Casualty Insurance Company vs. SCDOI - 5/1/1996
96-ALJ-09-0056-CC - - South Carolina Medical Malpractice Liability Insurance Joint Underwriting Association vs. SCDOI - 4/1/1996
96-ALJ-09-0058-CC - - Unisun Insurance Company, et al vs. SCDOI - 3/29/1996
96-ALJ-09-0059-CC - - Amica Mutual Insurance Company vs. SCDOI - 4/8/1996
96-ALJ-09-0073-CC - - United Services Automobile Association, et al vs. SCDOI - 4/3/1996
96-ALJ-09-0074-CC - - Investors Title Insurance Company vs. SCDOI - 4/23/1996
96-ALJ-09-0075-CC - - Hartford Fire Insurance Company vs. SCDOI - 4/30/1996
96-ALJ-09-0115-CC - - INSURANCE SERVICES OFFICE, INC. vs. SCDOI - 5/29/1996
96-ALJ-09-0119-CC - - FEDERATED MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY vs. SCDOI - 6/17/1996
96-ALJ-09-0120-CC - - Auto-Owners Insurance Company vs. SCDOI, et al - 6/7/1996
96-ALJ-09-0136-CC - - INSURANCE SERVICES OFFICE, INC. vs. SCDOI - 5/28/1996
96-ALJ-09-0137-CC - - UNIVERSAL INSURANCE COMPANY vs. SCDOI - 6/24/1996
96-ALJ-09-0151-CC - - Harleysville Mutual Insurance Company vs. SCDOI - 6/11/1996
96-ALJ-09-0152-CC - - Horace Mann Insurance Company vs. SCDOI - 6/13/1996
96-ALJ-09-0154-CC - - American Economy Insurance Company vs. SCDOI - 5/15/1996
96-ALJ-09-0161-CC - - Allstate Insurance Company, et al vs. SCDOI - 5/29/1996
96-ALJ-09-0190-CC - - Republic Mortgage Insurance Company vs. SCDOI - 7/16/1996
96-ALJ-09-0191-CC - - Jefferson Insurance Company of New York vs. SCDOI - 6/20/1996
96-ALJ-09-0233-CC - - State Auto Property and Casualty Insurance Company vs. SCDOI - 9/9/1996

1995

94-ALJ-09-0271-CC - - Boston Old Colony Insurance Company, et al vs. SCDOI - 1/1/1995
94-ALJ-09-0286-CC - - TIG Countrywide Insurance Company vs. SCDOI - 2/1/1995
94-ALJ-09-0293-CC - - United Financial Casualty Company vs. SCDOI - 1/12/1995
94-ALJ-09-0305-CC - - Hartford Insurance Company of the Midwest vs. SCDOI - 2/1/1995
94-ALJ-09-0320-CC - - American Association of Insurance Services vs. SCDOI - 1/30/1995
94-ALJ-09-0321-CC - - Horace Mann Insurance Company vs. SCDOI - 2/1/1995
94-ALJ-09-0324-CC - - Unisun Insurance Company, Amerisure Insurance Company, and Michigan Mutual Insurance vs. SCDOI - 1/19/1995
94-ALJ-09-0325-CC - - Hartford Insurance Company of the Midwest vs. SCDOI - 2/1/1995
94-ALJ-09-0327-CC - - State Farm Insurance Companies vs. SCDOI - 1/10/1995
94-ALJ-09-0346-CC - - Boston Old Colony Insurance Company, et al vs. SCDOI - 2/1/1995
94-ALJ-09-0390-CC - - The Home Insurance Company and City Insurance Company, et al vs. SCDOI - 2/1/1995
94-ALJ-09-0391-CC - - Hartford Casualty Insurance Company, et al vs. SCDOI - 4/28/1995
94-ALJ-09-0392-CC - - General Accident Insurance Company of America vs. SCDOI - 3/1/1995
94-ALJ-09-0401-CC - - Auto Owners Insurance Company, et al vs. SCDOI - 4/28/1995
94-ALJ-09-0402-CC - - Auto Owners Insurance Company, et al vs. SCDOI - 4/28/1995
94-ALJ-09-0403-CC - - South Carolina Reinsurance Facility vs. SCDOI, et al - 4/3/1995
94-ALJ-09-0412-CC - - State Farm Fire and Casualty, et al vs. SCDOI - 3/16/1995
95-ALJ-09-0005-CC - - VASA North Atlantic Insurance Company vs. SCDOI - 2/1/1995
95-ALJ-09-0006-CC - - Associates Insurance Company vs. SCDOI - 2/1/1995
95-ALJ-09-0021-CC - - National Grange Mutual Insurance Company vs. SCDOI - 5/1/1995
95-ALJ-09-0022-CC - - South Carolina Medical Malpractice Liability Insurance Joint Underwriting Association vs. SCDOI - 4/1/1995
95-ALJ-09-0023-CC - - National General Insurance Company vs. SCDOI - 5/1/1995
95-ALJ-09-0026-CC - - National Grange Mutual Insurance Company vs. SCDOI - 5/1/1995
95-ALJ-09-0055-CC - - National Council on Compensation Insurance, Inc. vs. SCDOI - 5/16/1995
95-ALJ-09-0086-CC - - Auto-Owners Insurance Company vs. SCDOI - 5/1/1995
95-ALJ-09-0088-CC - - Nobel Insurance Company vs. SCDOI - 5/22/1995
95-ALJ-09-0090-CC - - Nobel Insurance Company vs. SCDOI - 5/22/1995
95-ALJ-09-0097-CC - - State Farm General Insurance Company vs. SCDOI - 5/11/1995
95-ALJ-09-0101-CC - - Federated Mutual Insurance Company vs. SCDOI - 5/26/1995
95-ALJ-09-0129-CC - - Insurance Company of North America, et al vs. SCDOI - 5/26/1995
95-ALJ-09-0130-CC - - Insurance Services Office Commercial Risk Services, Inc. vs. SCDOI - 6/7/1995
95-ALJ-09-0198-CC - - Old Republic National Title Insurance Company vs. SCDOI - 7/12/1995
95-ALJ-09-0199-CC - - Heritage Indemnity Company vs. SCDOI - 7/12/1995
95-ALJ-09-0200-CC - - State Auto Property and Casualty Insurance vs. SCDOI - 6/20/1995
95-ALJ-09-0204-CC - - United Services Automobile Association, et al vs. SCDOI - 6/30/1995
95-ALJ-09-0205-CC - - State Auto Property and Casualty Insurance vs. SCDOI - 6/20/1995
95-ALJ-09-0206-CC - - Selective Insurance Company of the Southeast vs. SCDOI - 7/5/1995
95-ALJ-09-0210-CC - - TIG Premier Insurance Company vs. SCDOI - 6/20/1995
95-ALJ-09-0211-CC - - General Accident Insurance Company of America, et al vs. SCDOI - 6/20/1995
95-ALJ-09-0212-CC - - Hartford Fire Insurance Company, et al vs. SCDOI - 8/2/1995
95-ALJ-09-0214-CC - - Vigilant Insurance Company vs. SCDOI - 7/5/1995
95-ALJ-09-0249-CC - - National Grange Mutual Insurance Company vs. SCDOI - 7/12/1995
95-ALJ-09-0267-CC - - vs. SCDOI - 5/31/1995
95-ALJ-09-0405-CC - - Insurance Services Office, Inc., et al vs. SCDOI - 9/19/1995
95-ALJ-09-0406-CC - - United Services Automobile Association, et al vs. SCDOI - 9/15/1995
95-ALJ-09-0407-CC - - CUMIS Insurance Society, Inc. vs. SCDOI - 8/30/1995
95-ALJ-09-0441-CC - - Auto-Owners Insurance Company, et al vs. SCDOI - 8/31/1995
95-ALJ-09-0442-CC - - Independent Property, et al vs. SCDOI - 8/29/1995
95-ALJ-09-0445-CC - - Lititz Mutual Insurance Company vs. SCDOI - 9/1/1995
95-ALJ-09-0454-CC - - South Carolina Farm Bureau Mutual Insurance Company vs. SCDOI - 9/7/1995
95-ALJ-09-0486-CC - - The Hanover Insurance Company, et al vs. SCDOI - 9/12/1995
95-ALJ-09-0488-CC - - Boston Old Colony Insurance Company, et al vs. SCDOI - 9/5/1995
95-ALJ-09-0497-CC - - Insurance Services Office, Inc. vs. SCDOI - 10/30/1995
95-ALJ-09-0515-CC - - United States Fidelity and Guaranty Company vs. SCDOI - 9/28/1995
95-ALJ-09-0564-CC - - The Continental Insurance Company vs. SCDOI - 10/31/1995
95-ALJ-09-0570-CC - - National Casualty Company vs. SCDOI - 12/19/1995
95-ALJ-09-0571-CC - - South Carolina Farm Bureau Mutual Insurance Company, et al vs. SCDOI - 11/9/1995
95-ALJ-09-0600-CC - - Horace Mann Insurance Company vs. SCDOI - 11/9/1995
95-ALJ-09-0606-CC - - United Financial Casualty Company vs. SCDOI - 11/27/1995
95-ALJ-09-0607-CC - - Insurance Services Office, Inc. vs. SCDOI - 11/27/1995
95-ALJ-09-0608-CC - - Nationwide Mutual Insurance Company, et al vs. SCDOI - 11/27/1995
95-ALJ-09-0631-CC - - Allstate Insurance Company, et al vs. SCDOI - 11/27/1995
95-ALJ-09-0666-CC - - Nationwide Mutual Fire Insurance Company vs. SCDOI - 12/18/1995
95-ALJ-09-0667-CC - - Government Employees Insurance Company vs. SCDOI - 12/6/1995
95-ALJ-09-0680-CC - - vs. SCDOI - 12/6/1995

1994

94-ALJ-09-0273-CC - - American Bankers Insurance Company of Florida vs. SCDOI - 12/1/1994
94-ALJ-09-0276-CC - - United Casualty Insurance Company of America vs. SCDOI, et al - 10/18/1994
94-ALJ-09-0285-CC - - St. Paul Fire and Marine Insurance Comjpany, et al vs. SCDOI - 12/19/1994
94-ALJ-09-0326-CC - - Catawba Insurance Company vs. SCDOI - 11/1/1994

Home

ALC Rules

Forms

Decisions

Judges

Organizational Listing

OMVH

Annual Report and Fees/Fines

FAQs

Links

Contact Us